Featured Articles

Latest Post
Showing posts with label waste incineration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label waste incineration. Show all posts

Can polluting industry be made non-polluting by shifting it from "Red Category" to "Blue Category" by terming waste burning an "essential environmental service"?

Written By mediavigil on Wednesday, October 14, 2026 | 10:55 PM

Susan George, the author of Shadow Sovereigns: How Global Corporations Are Seizing Power (2015) was right about the role of capitalism in wasting resources, people, social cohesion, wealth and “planned obsolescence”. 
 
Referring to the observation of noted scientist Dr. Bruno Terne  made in 1893 at the Philadelphia Franklin Institute, Dr. Gopal Krishna, a practicing advocate and an environmentalist and the founder of ToxicsWatch Alliance (TWA), an alliance against ecocide and insectageddon delivered a speech on "Waste-to-energy: Impact on workers, communities and environment" as part Labour Justice Lecture Series, wherein, he denounced the 21 Municipal Solid Waste (MSW)-based Waste-to-Energy (WTE) plants which are currently operational across the country. Dr Bruno Terne had argued against burning natural fertilisers in incinerators while at the same time extracting and transporting fertilisers from continent to continent. He had said that in this century of progress, with our knowledge of chemistry, and with  the most complete machinery at our disposal, it seems like a lapse into barbarism to destroy this most valuable material simply for  the purpose of getting rid of it, while at the same time we are eager to obtain these very same materials for agricultural fields by purchase from other sources. 
 
Dr Krishna pointed out that disregarding public health crisis due to air pollution, union government has exempted Waste-to-Energy (WTE) plants from prior environmental clearance and in an indefensible act shifted them from Red category (high pollution potential) under the Central Pollution Control Board’s industry pollution index, to Blue category. This category was created in 2025 for “facilities essential to control, abate, and mitigate pollution generated from domestic and industrial activities”. Delhi's four waste power plants in Okhla, Ghazipur, Narela-Bawana and Tehkhand promotes biomass burning unmindful of the morbidity and mortality due to air pollution load and food chain contamination. This exposes the double speak of governments in Delhi who blame Punjab and Haryana farmers for burning biomass which causes air pollution related public health disaster in the national capital Region. Similar plant is proposed in Ramachak Bairiya, Sampatchak block of Patna district. 
 
Dr. Krishna's speech is here: 
 
Dr. Krishna dwelt on the issues of waste workers’ rights, privatisation and the politics of waste management. Indian urban population is over 54.27 crore. Although more than 90% of municipal solid waste is collected in India, only 5-4% receives adequate treatment, highlighting a significant gap between collection and effective processing. In practice, only 21 Municipal Solid Waste (MSW)-based Waste -to-Energy (WtE) plants have a cumulative installed capacity of 248.8 MW. 
 
Recalling the anti-environment and anti-public health legacy of Sheila Dikshit and Rakesh Mehta which has distorted waste management in the national capital region and elsewhere, Dr. Krishna located the public health crisis in a historical context. The first waste/refuse destructor, now called incinerator was built in Nottingham, England in 1874 to reduce the volume of municipal/ urban waste. It was the moment of the birth of bad idea. USA constructed its first incinerator on Governor's Island in New York in 1885. Germany adopted and altered it to establish it's first incineration plant in Hamburg in 1856. Japan built its first waste incinerator plant in Kobe in 1963. Singapore built its Ulu Pandan incineration plant in 1979. Among the BRICS counties, India established a Danish technology based plant in Timarpur, Delhi in 1987, which ram for 21 days. When Rajiv Gandhi, as Prime Minister visited it, the defunct waste incinerator plant was made to run on diesel, not by incinerating/burning waste. CAG's audit report of 1990 led to its official closure in 1990. 
 
Refusing to learn lessons from the recommendations of CAG, as Chief Minister of Delhi, Sheila Dikshit disregarded the letter of Jairam Ramesh, the then union minister of environment and forests. After visiting the Okhla based waste incinerator power plant, he had written to her pointing out several anomalies such as the failure to take the public into confidence in the prescribed manner. Notably, tests ordered by the National Green Tribunal has shown Dioxins, a dangerously toxic substance released by incineration, to be several times more than permissible limits. The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) did not have any means to test for dioxins continuously, online and on a readily verifiable basis. Residents have repeatedly complained to CPCB and Delhi Pollution Control Committee about excessive pollution released daily by the plant on a daily, causing eye irritation and breathing difficulties. The burning of waste results in the emission of a cocktail of pollutants – SOx, NOx, SPM, RSPM, dioxins, furans and heavy metals like lead, cadmium and mercury (from batteries and CFLs). As commissioner of Municipal Corporation of Delhi and later as Delhi's power secretary and chief secretary, Rakesh Mehta allowed himself to be misled by D. K. Mittal, the then CEO of The Timarpur Waste Management Company Pvt. Ltd. (TWMCPL), a subsidiary of Infrastructure Leasing & Financial Services Ltd. (IL&FS). Mittal was also a serving IAS officer, besides being the CEO, Special Infrastructure Projects, Infrastructure Leasing and Financial Services (IL&FS). They disregarded the White Paper of Union Ministry of Environment and Forests said that the failure of waste incineration plant at Timarpur, a project initiated in the mid-80s supported the fact that thermal treatment of municipal solid waste is not feasible in situations where the waste has a low calorific value. It added: "A critical analysis of biological treatment as an option was undertaken for processing of municipal solid waste in Delhi and it has been recommended that composting will be a viable option."   
 
Dr Krishna pointed out that Burning biomass is not green, it is not a source of renewable energy. Keeping in mind the characteristics of Indian municipal solid waste, a Supreme Court committee had recommended composting and recycling. It is relevant to recall that Delhi High Court's judgment dated January 15, 2013 established the health impacts from the incinerator based on existing medical literature. The High Court judgment reads: "Both older and more modern incinerators can contribute to the contamination of local soil and vegetation with dioxins and heavy metals. In several European countries, cow"s milk from farms located in the vicinity of incinerators has been found to contain elevated levels of dioxin, in some cases above regulatory limits. Increased levels of dioxins have been found in the tissues of residents near to incinerators in the UK, Spain and Japan. At an incinerator in Finland, mercury was increased in hair of residents living in the vicinity. Children living near a modern incinerator in Spain were found to have elevated levels of urinary thioethers, a biomarker of toxic exposure. " It notes that "After 2 years of operation of incinerator, dioxins levels were found increased by about 25% in both groups living between 0.5 to 1.5 and 3.5 to 4.0 km away (201 people) of people. In the repeat analysis, the increase was in the range of 10-15%". 

The judgment records that "Mothers living close to incinerators and crematoria from 1956 to 1993" showed "increased risk of lethal congenital abnormalities, in particular, spinal bifida and heart defects, near incinerators: increased risk of stillbirths and anacephalus near crematoria". With regard to "Residents from 7 to 64 years old living within 5 km of an incinerator and the incinerator workers" the judgment observes, "Levels of mercury in hair increased with closer proximity to the incinerator during a 10 year period".  The judgment recorded that "Residents living within 10 km of an incinerator, refinery, and waste disposal site" showed "Significant increase in laryngeal cancer in men living with closer proximity to the incinerator and other pollution sources". The *"Residents living around an incinerator and other pollution sources" showed "Significant increase in lung cancer related specifically to the incinerator". *The *"People living within 7.5 km of 72 incinerators" displayed "Risks of all cancers and specifically of stomach, colorectal, liver and lung cancer increased with closer proximity to incinerators".
 
All municipal waste combustors–regardless of technology–release a number of pollutants, including cadmium, lead, mercury, dioxin, sulfur dioxide, hydrogen chloride, nitrogen dioxide, and particulate matter. Dioxins and heavy metals like mercury are of particular concern because they are toxic, persist in the environment and accumulate in biological matter. The claim of waste technologies and waste to energy policies to solve the waste and climate crisis is dubious. The fact is that it upholds linear, extractive systems, exacerbating the waste crisis and climate crisis. They ignore root causes, harm communities, and distract from proven, community-led zero waste practices. They harm frontline and low-income communities. They delay meaningful action and climate targets, justify overproduction and consumption, waste public money and political will and undermines and distracts attention from real zero waste alternatives. Waste incineration is the most expensive and polluting way to manage waste or to generate energy.   
 
The Union Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change notified the Solid Waste Management (SWM) Rules, 2026. It covers waste management in both urban and rural areas. TWA had sought its expansion of the ambit of the Rules, when Municipal Solid Wastes (Management and Handling) Rules, 2000 was being framed. The new rules have superseded the 2016 Rules, which had superseded the Municipal Solid Wastes (Management and Handling) Rules, 2000, India’s first dedicated regulations for managing municipal solid waste under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986. It came into full effect from April 1, 2026. The revised rules refer to the principles of Circular Economy and Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) but fails to act as per these principles in letter and spirit. The Rules envisage an institutional arrangement which is “too centralised, too technocratic”. it ignores municipal autonomy and subsidiarity guaranteed under the 74th Constitutional Amendment. 

The promise of waste-to-energy projects made in the new Rules are anti-environment, and anti-people. The callousness of AAP, BJP and Congress towards the sad plight of residents of Okhla, Narela-Bawana and Ghazipur, environment and the livelihood of waste pickers due to hazardous waste to energy incinerators is unacceptable. No lessons have been learnt from the bitter opposition to waste to energy incinerator plants in Delhi, Telnagana and Bihar due to their adverse public health consequences. The plant in question has violated every rule in the rule book. It is a matter of fact that such plants have consistently failed in India.

The consent of the people is a ‘must’ before granting environmental clearances under the environmental laws. But now such projects seem to be enjoying a law holiday.  The cumulative impact assessment was never taken. The people of National Capital Region never gave their consent for this hazardous project in their proximity. There is documentary evidence that the public hearing that was conducted was fake, it was conducted at Saket.

The environmental clearance given to such projects are aimed at grabbing subsidies being offered by Ministry of New & Renewable Energy (MNRE) and to earn carbon credits from these polluting waste based power plants. The cumulative impact assessment of the pre-existing waste incinerator and the new municipal waste incinerator has never been done. The emissions from both these units are already becoming part of body burden of residents of national capital region and across the country. The minutes of the Environment Pollution (Prevention & Control) Authority for the NCR (EPCA) has revealed that Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) was asked about the actions taken to improve Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) management in Delhi. “To this MCD replied that individual waste to energy projects have been already given to Jindal, Ramky and GMR, which will result in minimal inert residue for land filling along with the generation of electricity,” the minute reads. This is factually deceptive and scientifically incorrect.

As per the Manual on Municipal Solid Waste Management, Union Ministry of Urban Development, physical composition of Indian waste shows that inert material constitutes from 43.59 % to 53.90 % and compostable matter constitutes 44.57 % to 30.84 %. Thus, the total inert residue from waste to energy incinerator projects will be significantly higher after the incineration of waste which will produce toxic ash as well that requires disposal in engineered landfills.

This grave situation has emerged due to evidently flawed waste to energy policy of central government, state government and the MCD which are providing incentives to hazardous incinerator and co-incineration incineration technologies like Refuse Derived Fuel (RDF).

Notably, the new rules provide for the levy of environmental compensation based on the ‘Polluter Pays’ principle for non-compliance, including cases of operating without registration, false reporting, submission of forged documents or improper solid waste management practices. The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) have prepared the relevant guidelines, while State Pollution Control Boards and Pollution Control Committee levy the environmental compensation. The new rules create specific waste management obligations like:

Four-Stream Segregation (Rule 5)
: Significantly, four-stream segregation of solid waste at source has been made mandatory under the SWM Rules, 2026. Waste is required to be segregated into wet waste, dry waste, sanitary waste and special care waste. 

Extended Bulk Waste Generator Responsibility (Rule 6): Entities with floor area exceeding 20,000 square meters, water consumption above 40,000 litres per day, or waste generation over 100 kg per day are required to process wet waste on-site or obtain Extended Bulk Waste Generator Responsibility (EBWGR) certificates. 

Landfill Restrictions (Rule 14): Only non-recyclable, non-energy recoverable, non-reusable, non-biodegradable waste may be landfilled. Higher tipping fees apply to unsegregated waste.

Notably, Rule 8 of the new SWM Rules introduces an economic incentive mechanism encourages local bodies to generate carbon credits through waste management activities but this is contrary to the core regulatory principle for carbon credits. The waste handling and disposal is an eligible sector for the voluntary Offset Mechanism Carbon Credit Trading Scheme (CCTS), established under the Energy Conservation Act, 2022. The Bureau of Energy Efficiency has established the institutional framework and elligibility criteria for the same. The CCTS framework local bodies, municipal corporations, and private waste management firms are permitted to earn CCCs where each certificate represents one ton of CO2 equivalent (tCO2e) reduced, removed, or avoided. 

The flaw with regard to additional action-apart from business usual action-which was there in the original waste to energy policy of the government of India remains intact. Given the fact that biomass burning for energy generation can neither be deemed either environmental action nor an additional environmentally sound action, carbon credits cannot be rewarded for additional environmental action. Such projects cannot be deemed to have complied with legal obligations either under the international climate law or national CCTS scheme. There is manifest conflict between carbon credit eligibility criteria Energy Conservation Act, 2022 and UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC), the parent international climate law on the one hand and the new SWM Rules 2026 which mandates segregation, composting, bio-methanation, RDF production, and landfill diversion, on the other hand. These activities constitute legal compliance only under one national law, the new SWM Rules but not under Energy Conservation Act, 2022 and the laws like Paris Agreement under the UNFCCC, which require additional environmental action. The requirement of “additionality” for carbon trade was envisaged under the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) of the Kyoto Protocol under UNFCCC to pave the way for earning carbon credit. It is intriguing that local bodies too have been encouraged to generate carbon credits as part of carbon trade, which is a fake environmental/climate  solution. 

Incineration by another name, use of Refuse Derived Fuel (RDF) by industries

The new rules define Refuse Derived Fuel (RDF) as fuel produced by shredding and dehydrating municipal solid waste with high calorific value, primarily consisting of non-recyclable plastic, paper and textiles. Industrial units, including cement plants and waste-to-energy plants that currently use solid fuel, have been mandated to replace it with RDF. This provision ignores the fact that waste incineration or co-incineration is a process which emits green house gases and persistent organic pollutants. It ignores the lessons from the failure of RDF based waste-to-energy  plant in Timarpur, which designed to incinerate 300 TPD of waste and produce 3.75 MW of electricity. 

Refuse Derived Fuel (RDF) Mandates (Rule 11): Industrial units within specified distances from RDF plants are required to replace solid fuel with RDF. The substitution rate increases from 6% (upon rule implementation) to 10% (after three years) to 15% (after six years).

The new rules mandate mapping and assessment of all legacy waste dumpsites and provide for time-bound biomining and bioremediation, with quarterly progress reporting through the online portal.  This is a positive provision. 

Dr Krishna concluded: "The opposition political parties must promise to work for abandonment of the harmful policy which promotes waste incineration based power plants to save irreparable damage to sustainable and sane municipal solid waste management practice. The Ministry of Power can vouch for the fact that the energy from municipal is inconsequential compared to the colossal public health concerns. Like the old MSW Rules, new rules ignore the emerging public health threats from the waste to energy incinerator in the vicinity of residential premises."  

The lecture program brought together workers, organisers, researchers and activists to examine how privatisation, waste management policies and waste-to-energy projects affect workers’ rights and livelihoods. It brought out the connection between labour rights, climate justice and laid a roadmap for developing recommendations for waste management that prioritises workers’ dignity, safety and participation. The participants recalled how waste workers keep cities clean and functional although they face insecure livelihoods, hazardous working conditions and exclusion shaped by caste, class and gender. The lecture was organised by Lokadhikar, Asangatith Mazdoor Sangarsh Morcha and SRUTI on September 22, 2026 at Indian Social Institute, Lodhi Road, New Delhi

Also read:Why Urban Waste Continues to Follow the Path of Least Resistance


Villagers in Jamsher, Jalandhar Cantt Reject Waste Incineration based toxic plant

Written By mediavigil on Saturday, June 06, 2020 | 2:05 AM

Current MLA Pargat Singh & ex- MLA 
Jagbir Singh Brar oppose Dioxins and Mercury Emitting Factory in Jamsher Village

Expressing his support for the agitation of villagers of Jamsher and adjoining villages and responding to concerns expressed by environmentalists, Jalandhar Cantt MLA and former Captain of Indian Hockey Team Pargat Singh says, "The solid waste management plant which was proposed in my constituency was logically, legally, technically and environmentally not right and people of my area are against it".

Vindicating the conerns regarding such toxic plants, un a significant related development, Canberra, the Australian Capital Territory (ACT) and National Capital and home to Australian Parliament and Federal Government has recently banned waste incineration.The ACT Greens party, led by Shane Rattenbury, was successful in having the state waste policy specifically exclude waste incineration.
In effect this is the first waste incineration ban in Australia and at a time when all other states are under extreme pressure to fast track these projects and embed waste incineration into their policies and scandalously, their circular economy policies. This ban now sets a new precedent for Australia and will likely have a positive influence in the Asia Pacific region.

Reference:https://reneweconomy.com.au/act-set-to-ban-waste-incineration-for-energy-citing-community-concerns-33706/
and https://www.canberratimes.com.au/story/6773715/burning-waste-off-the-cards-under-new-act-govt-energy-plan/?fbclid=IwAR0YEZYjRuiASSqNhUZgE0yga0wEgoUeGWe_P4UX7YfHily_SMFuerCLaLU

It is one small step for Australia...and one giant leap forward for zero waste, a circular economy and our toxics free future! National Toxics Network, ACT Greens, ACT state parliament and the awesome local groups who have made this possible, said Jane Bremmer of Zero Waste Australia & Campaign Coordinator and of National Toxics Network Australia
 
In Punjab, the agitation against toxic waste plant began in September, 2011 at a public hearing for obtaining environmental clearance for setting up of a Municipal Solid Waste (MSW) processing facility in Jamsher village by Municipal Corporation Jalandhar, it emerged that there was unanimous opposition to the project which involved waste burning for generation of electricity. The villagers feared threat to human health and environment from the toxic waste to electricity plant. The villagers from all the adjoining villages who are likely to be adversely affected expressed their bitter opposition to the proposed poisonous power plant.

The Department of Local Government, Government of Punjab has initiated to implement an “integrated MSW management facility for Jalandhar cluster comprising of Jalandhar city and 25 other Urban Local Bodies (ULBs).” This means that wastes from ULBs like Jalandhar, Adampur, Alawalpur, Banga, Begowal, Bhogpur, Bhulath, Dasuya, Dhilwan, Garshankar, Goraya, Hariana, Hoshiarpur, Kapurthala, Kartarpur, Lohian Khas, Mahalpur, Nakodar, Nawan Shehar, Nurmahal, Phagwara, Shahkot, Sham Chaurasi, Sri Hargobindpur, Sultanpur and Umar Tanda will be transferred to the plant site in Jamsher village. The villagers made it clear that come what may they will not allow the cancer causing plant in their region.

It was noted that in the Draft Environment Impact Assessment report prepared by SENES Consultants India Pvt Ltd on behalf of Municipal Corporation Jalandhar, Punjab and Infrastructure Leasing & Financial Services Limited (IL&FS)’s Infrastructure Development Corporation that the ‘Municipal Solid Waste Processing Facility’, will use incineration of Refuse Derived Fuel (RDF) technology. This is a biomass burning technology.

The villagers got agitated after officials failed to answer their public health related questions. 

As per the Draft Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) report, “The facility will comprise of a MSW processing facility at Jamsher village in Jalandhar district for processing the MSW from Jalandhar cluster and an engineered Sanitary Land Fill (SLF) site at Hoshiarpur town in Hoshiarpur district for disposal of processing rejects and other inert wastes generated by the processing facility.” Although it is quite clear that it is an EIA for electricity generation, the public hearing did not reveal it explicitly.

At the public hearing Punjab Pollution Control Board conceded that it does not have the capacity to even test persistent organic pollutants like dioxins. The project developer could not explain how they will segregate heavy metals like lead and mercury from the mixed waste which is to be burnt as per the EIA report.

Jagbir Singh Brar, ex-MLA, Jalandhar cantt, Punjab observed that “the public hearing for “Municipal solid waste processing facility” is quite strange. This is actually a waste burning project. It is a power project based on waste. The question is why has Punjab Pollution Control Board and the project developer hidden this fact from the public. I have learnt from newspapers and research reports that such plants have failed in India, why a failed project is being proposed here. A similar plant has failed in Timarpur in Delhi and in Andhra Pradesh. Delhi High Court had scolded the Govt. for such experimental technology in the past.”

He added, “Project Developer and Punjab Pollution Control Board are trying to confuse the public by not revealing that waste burning is highly polluting. It has not told the public about the health effects and diseases caused by waste burning plants. No health and environmental loving person can allow such polluting and disease causing plant in there place of residence. I am deeply concerned about the health of the villagers from the locality and its impact on the dairy. I on my own behalf and on behalf of the people of Jalandhar urge you to ensure that this Dioxins emitting technology of waste burning in the residential area is not allowed. This plant should not get environmental clearance in view of its adverse impact on public health and environment.” 

Dr. Gopal Krishna of ToxicsWatch Alliance (TWA) who was also present at the public hearing noted that while the project has two components comprising of “municipal solid waste processing facility” and an engineered Sanitary Land Fill, this EIA report only dealt with the former. The project has deliberately been broken into two parts to obviate combined resistance from the villagers of Jamsher and Hoshiarpur. This EIA report is misleading both the residents of Jamsher, Hoshiarpur the Jalandhar. The report states that the total area available for development of the “MSW facility is approximately 25 acres”. Why does it exclude Hoshiarpur’s 30 acre? As per the TOR given in the Draft EIA report for the MSW facility, some 20 points out of the 35 points mentioned refer to landfill but this document is silent about it.

It is claimed in the Draft EIA report that the MSW processing plant to consist of burning of RDF (Refuse Derived Fuel) plant, biomethanation plant, power plant (optional) and composting facility. The plant will be designed to process 700 Tonnes Per Day (TPD) of Municipal Solid Waste and is expected to generate around 260 TPD of Refuse Derived Fuel (RDF) in the form of fluff. The fluff is expected to have a Gross Calorific Value (GCV) of 2,500 Kcal/kg to 27,000 Kcal/kg. The plant will also be designed to process 50 TPD of green waste for producing biogas in a biomethanation plant and manure in a composting facility. The biogas generated is expected to be about 2,750 to 3,000 Nm3/day and manure quantity is expected to be about 6-7 TPD. The RDF plant and the biomethanation plant are expected to operate for 330 days in a year. The total cost of the integrated MSW processing facility is estimated to INR 99.21 crores. The project will be made operational in a span of 14 months, it is claimed.

It is confessed in the EIA report that waste collected from various sources in the Jalandhar cluster will have differing calorific values. It is not revealed how Indian waste, which has calorific value of 800-1000 kcal will gain the Gross Calorific Value) of 2,600+ kcal / kg after drying and separation of non-combustible and recyclable fraction and after conversion to RDF.

Dr. Krishna observed that If the project is to be implemented by companies like Jindal Urban Infrastructure Limited (JUIL), a company of M/s Jindal Saw Group Limited owned by Prithviraj Jindal, which has no previous experience in waste management, it will distort waste management beyond repair.

Given the fact that the project proponent is using RDF technology it is relevant to note that all such experiments based on this technology to treat waste has failed in the country. A similar plant proposal compelled the union Environment Minister to write to Delhi chief minister that there has been violation in basic condition stipulated in environment condition. It violates the recommendation of the environment Ministry.

In a White paper on Pollution, it has been underlined that Indian waste is suitable only for Biological Treatment Methods. It violates the recommendation of Supreme Courts committee on Waste to Energy that insisted on segregation of waste its source. Once waste is segregated, compostable waste can be composted and recycled waste can be recycled. In such a scenario, what is the need to burn the waste.

The power generated will be highly expensive. Experts suggest that it is 4-5 times costlier than the conventional electricity. The EIA report does not reveal how the project developer will deal with toxic ash which will contain heavy metals like mercury. If such ash is dumped in place like Hoshiarpur, it will adversely affects the health of the people of Hoshiarpur. In 1990’s, a similar waste Energy Plant was shut down in Delhi because the garbage had about 60% organic waste and large amount of silt. The waste of Jalandhar will not be any different.

Indian waste has some 60 % organic waste and some 25 % sand, dust and ash. Incineration of such waste is inadvisable. It promotes waste generation, what is required is waste prevention and reduction and zero waste system that guarantees returned on investments and healthy communities. There is threat to ground water from ash disposal. Incineration also creates huge amount of Air pollution. It also releases Carbon monoxide, oxides of sulphur and nitrogen, hydrocarbons and particulates in the air. Waste incineration emits Green House Gases as well. This technology has high public health cost. It causes cancers, birth defects in villagers living in the vicinity of incineration.

It is clear to the villagers of Jamsher and adjoining villages of Jalandhar Cantt that incineration is the most costly waste management option from the point of view of public health environment and natural resources. Therefore, the villagers contend that the power plant based on waste should not get approval. It is noteworthy that Union Ministry of New & Renewable Energy is damaging waste management in cities like Jalandhar by providing subsidy to such polluting projects. States must not allow themselves to be misled by this Union Ministry and should desist from approving such hazardous projects given the fact that health is a state subject under the Constitution. 

Punjab government should be wary of being driven by New Delhi based officials and vested interests who have unleashed misinformation campaign to undermine public health concerns regarding such environmentally damaging myopic projects


Picture 1- Pargat Singh, Picture 2-Protesting villagers, Picture 3-Proposed project site, Jamsher Village, Jalandhar Cantt

Movement launched against waste based thermal plant

Written By mediavigil on Wednesday, September 16, 2015 | 12:34 AM




State adopted outdated waste management techniques, say experts

Environmentalists today doubted the authenticity of the 2012 State Level Environment Impact Assessment Authority (EIAA) report approving the setting up of incinerator-based municipal solid waste thermal power plants across eight clusters in the state.

They also expressed concern over the harmful effects of the outdated municipal solid waste (MSW) management techniques being adopted by the Punjab government.
Addressing a workshop on MSW management here in Jalandhar, Delhi-based environmentalist and public policy expert Gopal Krishna said the incinerator technology was discarded by western and European countries 20 years ago and had failed in 24 projects set up in India after 1986.
He said opting for the outdated technology could lead to health hazards as dangerous as ‘chemical warfare’.
“The EIA report indicates the plants of dioxins emitting nature being proposed in a residential area unmindful of the fact that pollutants are passengers without passports that would enter the food chain and harm many future generations,” said Krishna.
He said solid waste companies were keen to set up MSW thermal power plants in the state as they were eying a subsidy of Rs 1.5 crore per MW to be issued by the Ministry of New and Renewable Energy for setting up of a waste-to-power plant. However, they would not succeed as the technology had been banned by the Supreme Court due to its harmful effects.
They said the setting up of incinerator-based power plants would bear no results as it was not suitable for the processing of waste produced in Punjab. They said around 78 per cent waste produced in the state constituted inert material (up to 53.9 per cent) and compostable matter (up to 30.84 per cent) which could not produce electricity because of its low calorific value.
“While the chemical composition of solid waste produced in Punjab is up to 1009.90 Kcal only; the waste required to produce electricity should be of calorific value higher than 2000 kcal,” they said.
Environmentalist Balbir Singh Seechewal today joined the movement, launched by SAD MLA Pargat Singh, to transfer the site of a solid waste management plant.
SAD MLA Pargat Singh said, “The state government should check the claims made by environmentalists on the harmful effects of the outdated technology and should also consider the concern of local residents.”


Another environmentalist Sudhir Sharma said a study conducted on people living around 72 incinerators showed that those living in 10 km of an incinerator, refinery and waste disposal site are most likely to have laryngeal cancer and other cancers specifically of stomach, colorectal, liver and lung.

Rachna Khaira
Tribune News Service
http://www.tribuneindia.com/news/punjab/community/state-adopted-outdated-waste-mgmt-techniques-say-experts/133205.html

Questions raised on waste-to-energy plant


JALANDHAR: Already facing opposition from villagers over setting up of solid waste management plant at Jamsher village of the district, environmental experts have raised more questions on the project at a seminar organized by Jalandhar Cantonment MLA Pargat Singh of the SAD, The MLA is also opposing the plant at the proposed site.

Gopal Krishna of Toxic Watch raised questions not only on the location of the proposed plant, but also compared it to chemical warfare stating it was a "tried, tested and failed" technology.

He pointed out that a white paper issued by the Union ministry of environment and forests (MoEF) had already made it clear that the technology being used for setting up the plant was not suitable for generating power.

"When the technology has already been rejected by the MoEF in the Indian context then why is it being tried here?" he asked. Jalandhar municipal corporation joint commissioner Rajeev Verma was also present during the seminar.

I P Singh

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/chandigarh/Questions-raised-on-waste-to-energy-plant/articleshow/48968671.cms



Movement launched against waste based thermal plant

One-day workshop on the solid waste management organised by Punjabi Satth Sabha, Lambra.


‘Punjab opting for outdated technology’

Terming the incinerator technology (burning of solid waste to produce electricity) opted by the Punjab Government to set up thermal power plants in all the eight clusters of state environmentalist and public policy expert Gopal Krishna said, “The state is opting for outdated technology that has been discarded by Western world around 20 years ago.” Also, he said, “The technology is banned by the Supreme Court as due to non segregation of the solid waste, it leads to the emission of the toxic gases like dioxin in the air.”

He also said that if state government goes ahead with the proposed technology, it could have serious implications like that of a ‘chemical warfare’ on the health of the people in the state.

Villagers raise doubts over Environment Impact Survey
Villagers raised serious doubts over the authenticity of environment impact survey conducted by a private consultant in 2011. They said that when they asked consultant about identifying the north direction of the site, they failed to do so in the public hearing held on September 30 in 2011. Also, the consultant failed to reply on the distance of nearest residential area from the proposed site, the distance to nearest Gurudwara, distance of Nanak Pindi village and many other queries pertaining to the facts mentioned in the survey report.

Sperm count reduced to half in 50 years
While revealing the harmful impact of millions of tonnes of solid waste lying untreated in the state, health expert Dr AS Azaad said untreated waste releases toxic emissions in the air that has affected the reproductive system and the physical and mental health of unborn babies in the state. “Various studies have shown that due to various environmental hazards, the sperm count in Punjab has reduced to half in the last 50 years. Also, it has affected the health of unborn children in the mother’s womb,” claimed Azaad. He also said earlier the sperm count was around 113 million that has now reduced to almost half, including dead sperms and also abnormal sperms. He said, “Presently, only 30 per cent sperm are presently effective as compared to the ones 50 years ago.”

Govt should review the technology

Area MLA Pargat Singh said, “There is a dire need to review the incinerator technology being adopted by the state government to save hundreds of villagers from the effect of harmful gases. There is no way villagers will allow the setting up of the thermal power plant in the area. It is high time that the government should either change the site or bring in latest technology approved by the national and international environment agencies.”

Industry too bats for the cause
Apart from the environmentalists and political leaders, noted industrialists from the sports, leather, hand and tool, farmers, sarpanchs of various villages and social welfare organisations participated in the workshop.


Rachna Khaira

http://www.tribuneindia.com/news/jalandhar/seechewal-joins-movement-against-thermal-plant/133358.html


 
Copyright © 2013. ToxicsWatch, Journal of Earth, Science, Economy and Justice - All Rights Reserved
Proudly powered by Blogger