Featured Articles

Latest Post
Showing posts with label Zero Waste. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Zero Waste. Show all posts

Protest against planned incinerator turns violent in in Chinese City

Written By Unknown on Monday, May 12, 2014 | 4:56 AM

The New York Times 
SHANGHAI — A huge demonstration against a planned waste incinerator in one of eastern China’s biggest cities turned violent on Saturday with protesters overturning and setting fire to police cars, leaving at least 10 demonstrators and 29 police officers injured, according to Xinhua, the official state-run news agency.
The authorities in the city of Hangzhou said on Sunday that they had cleared an expressway that was blocked by the rally a day earlier, and that 700 officers had been deployed there to maintain order. A city official also said that construction on the incinerator, in the city’s Yuhang district, would not go forward without public support and proper legal approvals.

The protest is the latest indication that China’s increasingly affluent residents are willing to challenge the government on health and environmental issues. Over the past few years, similar demonstrations have taken place in Shanghai, Shenzhen and other major cities aimed at halting the construction of chemical factories or waste incinerators that residents believe will threaten the health and safety of their families.

China’s state-run news media said 18 people were arrested last month in another large demonstration against a chemical plant in the city of Maoming, in southern Guangdong Province.

Big cities are rushing to build waste incinerators to keep pace with the country’s rapid growth and a surge in household waste. Growing awareness of the pollutants released around such plants has led to large protests.
While some expensive waste incinerators are environmentally sound, many less-expensive ones release heavy pollutants, like dioxin and mercury, that persist in the atmosphere.

The Hangzhou government told state-run news media that it understood the concerns of the protesters but that the existing four waste incinerators could not keep up with the growing garbage.

A version of this article appears in print on May 12, 2014, on page A7 of the New York edition with the headline: Protest of Planned Incinerator Turns Violent in Chinese City

AAP’s promise to shut down hazardous Okhla’s incinerator is commendable amidst Congress-BJP collusion

Written By Unknown on Friday, April 04, 2014 | 2:05 AM

AAP’s promise to shut down hazardous Okhla’s incinerator is commendable

Collusion of Congress, BJP promotes war chemical emitting toxic waste incinerators

http://www.thehindu.com/multimedia/dynamic/01719/13ndbin01_jinda_DE_1719982e.jpg
 (Picture: Prithiraj Jindal’s municipal waste to energy plant and the Niraj Agarwal’s biomedical waste incinerator.)
April 4, 2014: In a letter dated April 1, 2014 sent to residents of Sukhdev Vihar, Okhla who are protesting against adverse health impacts of waste incinerators, Col. Devinder Sehrawat, AAP candidate for South Delhi Lok Sabha constituency has promised that “when the AAP returns to power in Delhi, this plant would be shut down and if not, at least shifted to another suitable location with little loss of time. Hence, the voters of the area need to take the right decision at the polls.”

Residents have been holding demonstrations, fighting court cases, and meeting officials since 2009 seeking relief from the smoke and ash from Prithiraj Jindal’s municipal waste to energy plant and the Agarwal’s biomedical waste incinerator. ToxicsWatch Alliance (TWA) along with residents had given a petition to chief minister Arvind Kejriwal on January 11, 2014 and asked environment minister Saurabh Bhardwaj on January 27, 2014 to intervene and save the residents from both the plants.

TWA demands that the waste incinerators plants should be shut down for good because shifting a polluting unit of factory does not make it non-polluting. 

TWA has been underling the collusion between BJP and Indian National Congress to promote toxic municipal waste incinerators in Delhi's Narela-Bawana, Ghazipur and Okhla.
Doctors, judges and residents hold that toxic emissions from such plants have been linked to cancers, respiratory ailments and birth defects. "And it's not only Sukhdev Vihar which is suffering. Other affected colonies include New Friends Colony, Maharani Bagh, Ishwar Nagar, Jamia Nagar, Jasola Vihar and Sarita Vihar, besides Jamia Millia Islamia University, Holy Family Hospital and other institutions.

AAP candidate recalled that that “shutting down of the bio-medical waste treatment plant situated at Sukhdev Vihar was a manifesto promise of AAP during Delhi Assembly elections 2013.”

AAP candidate explained, “As promised in the election manifesto, during the rather short tenure of the APP Govt., we had initiated several steps to close the plant. However given the complex nature of governance in Delhi such as the involvement of various agencies such as MCD, Central Govt. etc in the decision making and due to the very short period of APP’s rule, regretfully nothing substantial could be achieved. You will appreciate that to be fulfilled; this task requires a longer period of time.” He concluded that “since the AAP Govt. has already set the process into motion” when AAP returns to power the matter will be taken to its logical conclusion.

It is noteworthy that as per Delhi High Court’s judgment of January 15, 2013, Okhla medical waste incinerator was supposed to be shut down by 15 July, 2013 but in contempt of court, the Synergy company, the biomedical waste incinerator operator did not do so. It filed a review application and has chosen not to comply with the Court's order with no consequence so far.

The High Court held that “We, therefore, direct respondent No. 2 Government of NCT of Delhi and respondent No. 7 M/s. Synergy Waste Management Pvt. Ltd. to shift the bio-medical waste disposal facility, being operated near Sukhdev Vihar, to a suitable site. The site suitable for shifting of the said facility in terms of this order would be identified by the Chief Secretary, Government of NCT of Delhi, within three months from today in consultation with DDA and DPCC and the facility in question would be shifted within three months thereafter, i.e., within 06 months from today. M/s Synergy is permitted to continue to operate the facility at the present site till it is shifted to a new site in terms of this order, or 06 months from today, whichever is earlier. If necessary, any further direction with respect to the shifting of the said facility, in terms of this order, will be sought from this Court. Both the petitions stand disposed of in terms of this order.”

The High Court dismissed the contention of M/s Synergy Pvt Ltd is far away from residential localities such as Sukhdev Vihar. On inquiry it was found that the distance between the said facility and their colony is less than 30 metres. The Synergy's biomedical waste incinerator plant is owned by Neeraj Agarwal and Dhiral Agrawal.

Besides biomedical waste incinerator, both the Delhi Government and the BJP led municipal corporations are promoting such municipal waste incinerator based power plants which emit chemicals like dioxins that were used in US-Vietnam war. Both the political parties are bringing in this technology. Their harmful policy can cause irreparable damage to sustainable and sane municipal solid waste management practices.
Residents of Sukhdev Vihar, Okhla are demanding that AAP Candidate of East Delhi Mohan Gandhi Read more should also promise that if he is elected, he will work to ensure the shutting down of this polluting plant which is located in a densely populated residential area.

Residents, environmental groups and waste recycling workers have now appealed to the citizens of Delhi to ensure that both the parties do not get their support until they change their stands on the waste-to-energy issue and ensure that the health of the citizens of the Capital is not compromised and Delhi is not turned into a health and environment disaster zone.

As per the Manual on Municipal Solid Waste Management, the Union Urban Development Ministry has noted that the physical composition of Indian waste shows that inert material constituent is from 43.59 per cent to 53.90 per cent and compostable matter constitutes are 44.57 per cent to 30.84 per cent. Thus, the total inert residue from waste-to-energy incinerator projects will be significantly higher after the incineration of waste which will produce toxic ash as well that requires disposal in engineered landfills.

For Details: Gopal Krishna, ToxicsWatch Alliance (TWA), Mb: 09818089660, 08227816731, E-mail: gopalkrishna1715@gmail.com, web:www.toxicswatch.org
Vimal Monga, for Sukhdev Vihar Residents, Mb: 9810499277

“Incinerator plants should be stopped in all residential areas”: Parliamentary Committee on Urban Development

Written By Unknown on Sunday, March 02, 2014 | 3:07 AM



Ministry of New & Renewable Energy misleads Parliamentary Committee on Okhla’s waste combustion based plant & Supreme Court’s order

In a landmark recommendation, Parliamentary Committee on Urban Development has recommended that “Incinerator plants should be stopped in all residential areas in all metropolitan & Big cities across the country” in its latest report to the Parliament.

This report vindicates the position of ToxicsWatch Alliance (TWA) that has been campaigning against such Incinerator plants in the country since 2001 along with resident welfare associations, waste recycling workers and environmental groups.

The report reads: “The Committee note that the Municipal Solid Waste is delivered by NDMC and MCD at the Okhla Power Plant site. Although it is claimed that “only non Hazardous Municipal Solid Waste will be treated at the facility”, the fact is that Delhi’s mixed municipal solid waste has characteristics of hazardous waste. MCD, Delhi government and Central Government have shown sheer callousness towards hazardous emissions from municipal incinerators that cause serious environmental and health problems to the people living not only near them but thousands of kilometers away from the source. The Committee feel anguished and dissatisfied with the reply of the Ministry that the soot in the atmosphere is reported to be within norms as it is monitored by Delhi Pollution Control Board. Therefore, the Committee recommend that these kinds of Waste Incinerator Plants should be stopped in all residential areas in all metropolitan & Big cities across the country.”

The attached the Report of the Parliamentary Committee on Urban Development that refers to the controversial Okhla based waste combustion based power project of Jindal Urban Infrastructure Ltd.
The report states, "During the hearing held on 15th May, 2007 in the matter relating to the stay on Govt. subsidies for projects on recovery of energy from municipal solid waste, Hon'ble Supreme Court has permitted the Ministry of New and Renewable Energy to go ahead with setting up of 5 waste-to-energy projects to study the viability of such projects. Hon’ble Supreme Court also directed that no projects for waste-to-energy be taken up till 5 pilot projects are completed. As per the aforesaid direction, the Ministry of New and Renewable Energy formulated “Programme on Energy Recovery from Municipal Solid Waste for Setting-up of 5 Pilot Projects”. The programme provides central financial assistance @ 2.00 crore per megawatt limited to Rs. 10.00 crore per project for 5 pilot set up by State Nodal Agencies, Urban Local Bodies/ Municipal Corporations or entrepreneurs. So far 5 projects have been approved in the cities Bengaluru, Hyderabad, New Delhi and Pune..."

It mentions one of these five projects as M/s Timarpur Okhla Waste Management Pvt. Ltd., (TOWMCL), Jindal ITF Centre, 28 Shivaji Marg, New Delhi (Promoted by Jindal Urban Infrastructure Ltd. The location is mentioned as Old NDMC Compost plant, New Okhla tank, New Delhi.

The reference to this Okhla based plant as one of the 5 projects is deceptively worded to give the impression that it is one of those 5 projects which was approved by the Supreme Court. The RTI reply has already revealed that it was not one of those 5 projects.   

Notably, the Report of the Parliamentary Committee on Energy also refers to Okhla waste to energy project. TWA had met Mulayam Singh Yadav, Chairman, Parliamentary Committee on Energy to submit a memorandum seeking closure of Jindal's waste incinerator and briefed him about it. TWA had also briefed Sharad Yadav, Chairman, Parliamentary Committee on Urban Development in person.

The report of the Parliamentary Committee on Urban Development states, "The Committee find that there are three major Sanitary Land Fill (SLF) sites in Delhi (Ghazipur, Okhla and Bhalaswa- Jahangirpuri,) which have turned into huge mountains of garbage and far exceeded their life span." Notably, Okhla is not and has not been a landfill. There is some deep mischief at work in declaring it as landfill.

For Details: Gopal Krishna, ToxicsWatch Alliance (TWA), Mb: 08227816731, 09818089660, Web: www.toxicswatch.org


Okhla colonies turning into toxic gas chamber due to Jindal’s waste incinerator

Written By Unknown on Saturday, February 22, 2014 | 3:10 AM


ToxicsWatch Alliance (TWA)

To

Shri Najeeb Jung
Hon’ble Lt. Governor
National Capital Territory of Delhi
Raj Niwas
Delhi

Date: 22 February, 2014

Through Smt. Nutan Guha Biswas Principal Secretary to Lt Governor

Subject-Okhla colonies turning into toxic gas chamber due to Jindal’s waste incinerator based power plant, photographs of Feb 21, 2014 attached

Sir,

This is to draw your urgent attention towards the fact that colonies in Okhla are turning into toxic gas chamber due to the Okhla Waste to Energy Incinerator plant by JITF Urban Infrastructure Limited (Jindal Ecopolis) that has violated every rule in the rule book. A polluting waste to energy plant in the residential area ignores the experience of Bhopal Gas Leak Disaster.
We submit that the plant is using untested and unapproved Chinese incinerator technology in complete violation all laws and environmental clearance of 2007 including its own project design document and environment impact assessment report. Chinese technology provider is from Hangzhou New Century Company Ltd of Hangzhou Boiler Group. The power plant in question has been set up by M/s Jindal Urban Infrastructure Limited (JUIL), a company of M/s Jindal Saw Group Limited owned by Prithviraj Jindal. Jindal’s waste incinerator based power plant.
We submit that in a letter to Shri J.S.Kamyotra, Member Secretary, Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) and Member Secretary, Delhi Pollution Control Committee (DPCC), Dr U C Bahri, a member of Okhla Anti Incinerator Committee (OAIC) wrote, “Living in Sukhdev Vihar and adjacent colonies is becoming impossible. Okhla WTE plant keeps on releasing smoke along with bad smell. we expect a strong action Photographs taken today dt 21-02-2014 attached.”
We submit that in another letter dated February 21 sent to Registrar, National Green Tribunal, Advocate Rakesh Kumar wrote, “Every day the Okhla Waste to Energy Plant rains on the residents of Sukhdev Vihar toxic ash with unbearable, nauseating and headache causing polluted air. Today it is particularly bad. Since yesterday night, in every single breathe there is burning smell. We have been completely deprived of our right to clean air. Entreat you on behalf of all the residents to protect us from being gassed in this inhuman manner.”   

We are confident that in face of wanton greed of the JITF Urban Infrastructure Limited (Jindal Ecopolis) for profit at any human cost, you will protect the health of the present and future generation of residents of Delhi’s Okhla.    
We wish to place on record the damning fact that the environmental clearance to this project was given when Mr A Raja was the Union Minister for Environment & Forests ignoring the protests of environmental groups, residents and waste recycling workers.
We wish to inform you that your office was informed about this impending public health crisis in January 2011 as well when a rally was held and its delegation submitted the memorandum seeking closure of the plant in question.
We submit that this plant is releasing war chemicals like dioxins and furans, persistent organic pollutants (POPs), which United State used in Vietnam War under the brand name Agent Orange. It may be noted that POPs is regulated by UN laws Stockholm Convention on POPs that lists incinerators as emitters of POPs like Dioxins. 
We submit that the Grievances against the Jindal’s municipal waste incinerator and biomedical waste incinerator have been registered with Grievance No: 2014747 and 20142534 at Delhi Chief Minister's office and the Delhi Environment Minister had initiated steps to deal with the problem.
We submit that air pollutants are passengers without passports. Okhla colonies which are getting engulfed from the dust and pollution from the plant include New Friends Colony, Maharani Bagh, Ishwar Nagar, Sukhdev Vihar, Jamia Nagar, Jasola Vihar and Sarita Vihar Jamia Millia Islamia university, Holy Family hospital and several other colonies and institutions. While the Supreme Court has only allowed pilot projects using the technology to be set up in India, the Okhla plant is in violation of the court’s order as has been revealed through RTI replies.
We urge you to take cognizance of the sad plight at waste to energy site in Gandhamguda village in Ranga Reddy district of Andhra Pradesh which had the same technology. While the incinerator was in operation, the village was covered by a heavy shroud of dark smoke. After the plant came up, local doctors started detecting case of problems not found before— skin rashes, asthma, respiratory problems and some cases of stillborns. In a statement, Gandhamguda sarpanch Smt D. Shakuntala said: ‘‘Everyone in Peerancheru Gram Panchayat and its adjoining regions is now contaminated with harmful pollutants and symptoms are visible in the form of brain fever, vomiting, jaundice, asthma, miscarriages, infertility.’’ Similar fate awaits residents of Delhi. It would not be appropriate to turn Delhi residents as guinea pigs for experimental and unapproved Chinese incinerator technology.
We submit that unmindful of the public protest, New Delhi Municipal Corporation (NDMC) had permitted Jindal Ecopolis to set up this plant. This will distort capital city’s waste management beyond repair. The NDMC signed an MOU with M/s ILFS in August 2005 (Council Resolution No 6(W-1), Dated 26/8/05) for setting up a project for complete utilization of solid waste. The project was ambiguously as Public Private Partnership (PPP) project for Development of an Integrated Waste Treatment Complex at Okhla Compost Plant site. Till April 2005, Timarpur Waste Management Company Limited (TWMCL), a special purpose  vehicle of ILFS was to undertake the task. To begin with TWMCL entered into a 25-year concession agreement with the Municipal Corporation of Delhi and the New Delhi Municipal Council under a PPP framework to set up a 650 tons-per-day (TPD) Refuse Derived Fuel (RDF) processing facility, a 50 TPD bio-methanation plant, a 6 MW power plant, and a 6 million gallons per day (MGD) sewage treatment plant at a total cost of Rs. 591.27 million (US$ 13.13 million). Later, Unique Waste Processing Company, a subsidiary of Infrastructure Leasing and Financial Services (IL&FS) and Andhra Pradesh Technology Development Centre (APTDC) has incorporated Timarpur-Okhla Waste Management Company for developing the project for processing municipal waste and also to produce electricity at two locations namely Timarpur and Okhla, at the site at Okhla that is adjacent to defunct Okhla Sewage Treatment Plant (STP). The TIMARPUR-OKHLA Waste Management Company Private Limited of ILFS transferred the task to Jindal Ecopolis after environmental clearance process was undertaken by ILFS. Since then both MoU and environmental clearance has been amended several times seemingly to corner subsidy of Rs 1.5 crore/ MW for waste to energy projects from the Ministry of New & Renewable Energy in contempt of Supreme Court’s order of 2005 ad 2007 in the Writ Petition (Civil) 888 of 1996. The next date of hearing is on April 22, 2014 in which a “Contempt Petition” is pending.   
We submit that in the presence of A.S. Chandihok, Additional Solicitor General, the bench headed by the Chief Justice, Delhi High Court in an order dated 15th January, 2010 observed, “that the project in question” and “the location of the pilot project in Delhi was neither recommended by the Expert Committee nor approved by the Supreme Court.”
We submit that the Timarpur-Okhla carbon credit project was registered on 10th November, 2007 although it is a green house emitting waste incineration project.
We submit that this project has met with protest rallies from the residents of Okhla. Waste incineration systems (including waste pelletisation, pyrolysis and gasification systems) produce pollutants, which are detrimental to health & environment. It is expensive and does not eliminate or adequately control the toxic emissions from today's chemically complex municipal discards. Even new incinerators release toxic metals, dioxins, and acid gases. Far from eliminating the need for a landfill, waste incinerator systems produce toxic ash and other residues. Such projects disperse incinerator ash throughout the environment and subsequently enter our food chain. It prohibits the development of local waste recycling-based businesses.
We submit that the plant is functioning contrary to national legislations and norms such as Municipal Solid Waste (Management & Handling) Rules, 2000 because according to these Rules it is illegal to incinerate chlorinated plastics (like PVC) and wastes chemically treated with any chlorinated disinfectant and recommendations of the Supreme Court constituted committee on waste management.
We submit that this toxic plant sets a very bad precedent for other cities as well. It has given birth to serious concerns about the health and safety of the citizens.
In view of these grave concerns, we request you to direct the concerned authorities to take preventive steps in order to save Delhi's Okhla residents and the bird sanctuary from highly polluting plant in residential areas by closing this plant at the earliest before it is too late.
Thanking You

Yours Sincerely
Gopal Krishna
ToxicsWatch Alliance (TWA)
First Floor,
124A/6, Katwaria Sarai,
New Delhi- 110016
Tel:91-11-65663958
Fax: 91-11-26517814
Mb: 9818089660
Cc
Ms. Sarita Chaudhary, Mayor, South Delhi Municipal Corporation
Shri Manish Gupta, Commissioner, South Delhi Municipal Corporation
Shri Jalaj Shrivastava, Chairperson, New Delhi Municipal Council
Shri Vikas Anand, Secretary, New Delhi Municipal Council
Dr. Harsh Vardhan, State President, Delhi State, Bhartiya Janta Party
Shri Arvind Kejriwal, Aam Aadmi Party
Shri Arvinder Singh Lovely, President, Delhi Pradesh Congress Committee (DPCC)
Smt. Swati Sharma, Additional Secretary to LG
Shri R. N. Sharma, Additional Secretary to LG
Shri Ajay Chaudhary, OSD to LG
Shri Vishwendra, Private Secretary to LG
Shri. Sumanta Chakraborty, Deputy Secretary (Administration) 
Chairperson, Association of Municipalities and Development Authorities (AMDA), Delhi

 

Delhi: Waste plant draining out local residents

Written By Unknown on Thursday, February 13, 2014 | 12:33 AM

Note: On February, 2, 2014 at about 11.15 am, residents observed fly-ash falling and cars, balconys, plants and varandas getting covered with a layer of dust. The chimney of the MSW WTE plant, Okhla was emitting smoke and fly-ash. The matter was reported to Vinod Babu and B.L. Chawla over mobile, SMS and email. They were requested to visit the Sukhdev Vihar colony and assess the level of pollution. At about 12.15 am, a group of residents, reached the plant to inform about the incident. The LED display board was showing pollution within limits.The Particulate Matter level was shown as 125 mg/Nm3. The plant representative informed about the failure of a boiler. Having discussed with senior, they decided to close the boiler. It is evident, the plant has some inherent design problems and the operators are not able to control the pollution. 
On behalf of the residents of Sukhdev Vihar Vimal Monga said, "We fail to understand, when the proponent has assured to comply with EU emission standards, then why you refer to the laxed Indian rules. The siting norms has relevance only because of such accidents. Even in case of accident, at least the public health /life, should not be at risk. Keeping in view, the frequency of accidents, even after numerous warnings from authorities and court, public health at stake, the residents of Sukhdev Vihar demand the pollution control authorities, to issue closer order without any further delay." 

Meanwhile, faculty and students from Delhi University under the banner of Scientists for Society are undertaking a study to fathom the emerging crisis besides science students volunteering to study it as a subject of environmental mismanagement.  


Gopal Krishna
ToxicsWatch Alliance 

Delhi: Waste plant draining out local residents 
Darpan Singh, Hindustan Times  

New Delhi, February 03, 2014
Every time Naintara Devraj gets up in the morning, she feels sick and groggy. Thick black smoke swirls around her residence at Sukhdev Vihar through the night.
“There is a perpetual, acrid smell in the air, like in a crematorium. Sometimes there is the distinct smell of plastic burning. Often the smoke mixes with the fog and remains over rooftops,” the 47-year-old housewife says.
She is not alone. There are many who say a waste-to-energy plant emits brownish, soapy ash, causing eye irritation and difficulty in breathing. They say ash sits on houses, cars and plants and furniture; it can leave a stain on the skin and burn holes on clothes hung out to dry.
Vanya Joshi (51), a filmmaker, says, “My doctor tells me that the smoke from the chimneys has affected my immune system. I do not smoke but my lungs have developed black patches. If this continues I will have to sell my flat and move somewhere safer.”
Residents say they have been holding demonstrations, fighting court cases, and meeting officials for two years now, seeking relief from the smoke and ash.
Gopal Krishna of anti-pollution NGO Toxic Watch Alliance said, “We gave a petition to chief minister Arvind Kejriwal on January 11. We asked environment minister on January 27 to intervene.”
http://www.hindustantimes.com/Images/popup/2014/2/03-02-14pg4anew.jpg
Another resident, Rishi Bansal, has complained to government authorities. “I was playing football in a park. A sudden cloud of smoke came from the direction of the plant and settled all around us. Finally, we had to quit the game,” he said.
Residents claim toxic emissions from such plants have been linked to cancers, respiratory ailments and birth defects. “And it’s not only Sukhdev Vihar which is suffering. Other affected colonies include New Friends Colony, Maharani Bagh, Ishwar Nagar, Jamia Nagar, Jasola Vihar and Sarita Vihar, besides Jamia Millia Islamia University, Holy Family Hospital and other institutions,” said Krishna.
A delegation of Okhla AntiIncinerator Committee (OAIC) has also submitted to Delhi the environment minister documents “which nail the lies of the company that runs the plant and the regulators.” Ranjit Devraj, another resident, said, “We have submitted proof that the union environment minister wrote to the Delhi CM, questioning public hearings on whose basis clearances were given to the plant.”
Though Hindustan Times could not independently verify the claims of the residents, pollution control authorities have in the past found that pollution levels were above permissible limits. Delhi Pollution Control Committee member secretary Sandeep Mishra admitted: “The plant has violated pollution-control norms four times in the last two years.”

Govt mulls final warning for Okhla waste-to-energy plant (HT)

Delhi Environment Minister’s assurance on Okhla plant welcome but DPCC’s legacy of complicity remains a concern

Written By Unknown on Friday, January 31, 2014 | 4:23 AM

Legacy of environmental lawlessness must be undone, an urgent inquiry into the questionable affairs of DPCC is a must   

Zero Waste approach should be adopted to deal with garbage crisis, not NIMBYism
Delhi Environment Minister, Saurabh Bhardwaj’s promise of action against Okhla waste incinerator plant is a welcome change from the previous regime but Delhi Pollution Control Committee (DPCC)’s legacy of complicity remains a matter of concern. Residents of Okhla and environmental groups are hopeful that the consent to establish (No Objection Certificate) given by DPCC to the plant in question will be withdrawn to save Delhi from an avoidable environmental health crisis. This will be a step to undo the legacy of environmental lawlessness in Delhi.

DPCC is guilty of having facilitated the fake public hearing for the plant which led to the grant of NOC and environmental clearance in 2007. For a plant in Okhla, the hearing was done in Saket in presence of just three persons who were officials of the government and even this was announced for “waste processing facility” not for waste to energy (WTE) plant. This fact has been noted in writing by the then Union Minister of Environment & Forests in a letter to the previous Chief Minister but she being anti-environment and anti-people chose to collude with the waste incinerator company in question.  This letter was shared with the Delhi Environment Minister by the delegation.

The Okhla Waste to Energy (WTE) Incinerator plant by JITF Urban Infrastructure Limited (Jindal Ecopolis) has violated every rule in the rule book including environmental clearance conditions with complicity from the DPCC. An inquiry must be ordered to examine the dubious circumstances in which environmental regulations were admittedly violated with impunity. Based on the documents on record, complaints of the residents, the letter of Union Minister of Environment & Forests, fraudulent misrepresentation of facts regarding the project being in accordance with the Supreme Court’s order, minutes of the public hearing and the EIA report, there is a compelling logic for conducting an inquiry and fixing accountability for the acts of omission and commission of the officials in this matter.      
  
This lawlessness was unleashed on the residents of Okhla and Okhla Bird Sanctuary by Prithiviraj Jindal’s waste to energy plant based on unapproved and experimental Chinese technology. DPCC has consistently been indulgent and has been misleading the authorities disregarding the fact of Okhla colonies which are getting engulfed from the dust and pollution from the plant including New Friends Colony, Maharani Bagh, Ishwar Nagar, Sukhdev Vihar, Jamia Nagar, Jasola Vihar and Sarita Vihar Jamia Millia Islamia university, Holy Family hospital and several other colonies and institutions. 
The fact is that burning or incineration or combustion is unambiguously polluting. It may be noted that mother's milk in areas where waste burning takes place has already been tested and found to contain high amount of dioxins. Dioxins, are well known carcinogenic chemicals. Incinerators also emit greenhouse gases, especially from plastics. Incineration drives a negative spiral of increased energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions. Also, restrictive policies in typical incinerator contracts require a set amount of garbage. These contracts impose fees that that are a disincentive for a city to improve waste prevention strategies (i.e. reduction), recycling and composting collections.

Instead of making Delhi citizens suffer from such hazardous technologies there is a need for integrated zero waste management. Take the case of Gandhi Nagar, a town panchayat of around 2,400 families in Vellore district, Tamil Nadu. Gandhi Nagar generates garbage of over 48 tonnes per year. This garbage is converted into manure and recyclable waste generating over Rs.3 lakh in revenue, and the scheme provides employment to local people. Such measures promote sustainable development as against the current trend of introducing failed polluting technologies, which turn citizens into guinea pigs for experiments. Zero Waste approach should be adopted to deal with garbage crisis, not NIMBYism (Not in My Back Yard). Waste should not be shifted from richer localities to poorer localities.   

The Inter-Ministerial Task Force on Integrated Plant Nutrient Management has recommended setting up of 1000 compost plants all over the country and has allocated Rs.800 crore for the same in the year 2005. This report has been submitted in the Supreme Court in the writ petition (civil) no. 888/1996) case. Notably, this report recommends composting as a measure for waste management instead of energy recovery because Indian soil is carbon deficit.
The ideal resource management strategy for municipal solid waste is to avoid its generation in the first place. This implies changing production and consumption patterns to eliminate the use of disposable, non-reusable, non-returnable products and packaging. The alternative waste disposal methods include waste reduction, waste segregation at source, extended use and refuse, recycling, biomethanation technology and composting. Zero Waste approach should be adopted to deal with garbage crisis, not NIMBYism


In sum, the waste incinerator projects are technologically incompatible with reducing dioxins emissions and at the same time relies on minimum guaranteed waste flows. It indirectly promotes continued waste generation while hindering waste prevention, reuse, composting, recycling, and recycling-based community economic development. It costs cities and municipalities more and provides fewer jobs than comprehensive recycling and composting. It prohibits the development of local recycling-based businesses.

In keeping with the characteristics of Indian municipal solid waste -- low calorific value, high moisture content, high proportion of organic matter, and considerable inerts like earth, sand and grit – that the Supreme Court Committee on Solid Waste Management suggested simple technologies and easily achievable standards with liberal timeframe knowing the limitations of urban local bodies and their institutional capabilities. It made recommendations to improve the finances of urban local bodies and to boost the composting of waste and recycling industry in this field. Recycling can eliminate a large chunk of the problem. Wet biodegradable wastes (e.g. cooked and uncooked foods and flowers) make excellent for composting. Indian soil is deficient in carbon and that is also the need of the hour to enrich the soil. In the US alone, recycling conserves an equivalent of approximately 11.9 billion gallons of gasoline, and reduces greenhouse gas emissions equivalent to taking one-fifth (40 million) of all US cars off the roads every year.

The move by the incineration industry to term waste incinerators as 'renewable energy' projects is not only fraudulent but also dangerous. The 25 year power purchase agreement for purchase of 50 % of what is generated (4-5 MW) by the Jindal’s plant in Okhla must be rescinded in view of the above facts. Municipal solid waste is not considered to be a renewable energy source since it tends to be a mixture of fuels that can be traced back to renewable and non-renewable sources. An inquiry is needed to examine as how much power has been generated and added by this unit. The agreement was signed under the misleading assumption that WTE is renewable energy. The advocates of incinerators prefer to pre-empt segregation and recycling efforts being made by municipalities and communities around the world. The National Green Tribunal (NGT) is due to hear the matter at next date of hearing is on 19-02-2014.

A delegation of Okhla Anti-Incinerator Committee (OAIC) and ToxicsWatch Alliance (TWA) met the minister on January 27, 2014 to apprise him of the scandal of the waste based power plant and shared documents which nail the lies of the company that runs the plant and the regulators. 

For Details: Gopal Krishna, ToxicsWatch Alliance (TWA), Mb: 09818089660, Mb:gopalkrishna1715@gmail.com, Web: www.toxicswatch.org 

 
Copyright © 2013. ToxicsWatch, Journal of Earth, Science, Economy and Justice - All Rights Reserved
Proudly powered by Blogger