Rally on Sunday at 11:00 amDear all,
As all of you would know that our visit/dharna at Ministry of Environment & Forests i.e. outside Jairam Ramesh's office was quite a success as an event but still lot more to be done. It gave a very high visibility to the problem almost all the leading media houses covered the issue. In our continued effort to ensure that this plant doesnt see light of the day, there is a rally on 27th March 2011 i.e. Sunday at 11:00 a.m.
We thank all those who have been regularly participating in the campaign and would continue to request others to please come out this time. Every additional participant makes a difference.
We are doing our bit for the cause and requesting you to come and join this campaign.
Assembling point : Outside Sukhdev Vihar D.D.A Flats, Pkt A & B
On behalf of all the aggrieved residents
Okhla Anti-Incinerator Committee
Asha Arora, Member, Mb: 9711408421
For further details visit: toxicswatch.blogspot.com or call Gopal Krishna, ToxicsWatch Alliance,
Mb: 9818089660, E-mail: email@example.com
P.S: There was a angry rally against incinerator based waste to energy projects in Delhi on 23rd March since these hazardous projects are a threat to livelihood and health. A petition was submitted to the Lt Governor.
Delhi’s bid to earn money through waste-to-power projects has been opposed by residents of neighbourhoods where the plants are coming up. Ragpickers, who believe the projects will cost them their livelihoods, are up in arms too. The Delhi government has planned three projects — one each in Okhla, Ti mparpur and Ghazipur — to generate over 41 MW. The projects are registered under the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) of the United National Framework Convention of Climate Change (UNFCCC) to earn credits on the carbon emissions saved to generate power.
“We earn Rs 50 to Rs 100 per day by lifting recyclable articles from garbage dumps,” said Raju Rajasthani, a ragpicker at the Bhalswa dump in north Delhi. “As the entire garbage would be treated in the plants, we will become redundant.” Ragpickers have some support from the residents of Okhla, Jamia Nagar, Ghaffar Manzil, Abul Fazl Enclave and Noor Nagar, but for a different reason. They are protesting against the location of the Okhla plant; it’s too close to their homes, they say. “The plant will kill the environment,” said Jamia Nagar resident KS Ahmed.
Union Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh has asked Chief Minister Sheila Dikshit to look into the objections. “If people are against them, their apprehensions should be dealt with,” he said. A ministry white paper said the plants will generate dioxins and other toxic emissions, which could harm public health.
“People’s concerns have been looked into. Some non-governmental organisations are creating problems,” said a civic official on condition of anonymity as he is not authorised to speak to the media.
Waste pickers along with environmentalists and civil society groups staged a march from Kudeshiya Park to the Lieutenant-Governor's office here protesting against the setting up of three waste-to-energy plants in the city.
The protesters said the three incinerator plants at Okhla, Timarpur and Gazipur were being built with complete disregard to the public health concerns of the area residents.
They said the livelihood of rag-pickers would be severely impacted as recyclable waste will be burnt. Also, the plant will emit hazardous pollutants, they alleged.
Residents of Batla House, Jamia Nagar, Ghaffar Manzil, Abul Fazl Enclave and Noor Nagar have been protesting against the plant in Okhla.
Waste to Energy Facility in Delhi Causing Controversy with Residents
The Okhla-Timarpur thermal Waste to Energy plant in Delhi, India will no longer be associated with the Asian Development Bank (ADB) according to a report in The Times of India. ToxicsWatch Alliance (TWA) had shared its correspondence with ADB. The incineration-based plant in Okhla is under construction and is scheduled to start operations in November 2011.
Asia Pacific Carbon Fund (APCF) had agreed to co-finance the project which, the parent company says, will reduce almost 263,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide emissions annually. The plant will incinerate 643,000 tonnes of Delhi's waste, generating 16 MW power plant. The initial investment in the project is about Rs 1.74 billion ($38 million)
The plant had initially been due to enter service in October 2009, but has been delayed primarily due to environment related objection from local residents. D Nayantara, a local resident told The Times of India: "An incineration plant in the middle of a residential area is really a poor idea. The government has still not given answers on how the waste will be carted to this site or how and where it will be segregated."
"There are several studies, including a white paper by the ministry of environment and forests, to show that composting is the best solution for Indian waste." Nayantara added. Initial assessment of the project was conducted based on the CDM-Project Design Document (PDD).
One senior representative told The Times of India that the nature of the project when assessed was an integrated waste to energy project as mentioned in the PDD. An agreement with the project developer was signed to provide carbon co-financing from APCF, which was subjected to fulfilment of certain condition precedence in the given time frame, including ADB due-diligence of the project.
"Conditions were not satisfied by the project developer, and, therefore, the agreement has expired. APCF is no longer associated with Timarpur-Okhla Waste Management Company Pvt Ltd's integrated waste to energy project in Delhi and no funds were released for this project," said the APCF representative.
Residents of areas near the project site have been protesting against the incineration plant saying that it will lead to pollution in the area, and the matter has been taken to court. At a meeting of the chief minister and representatives of the power company the issue of foul smells emanating from the existing Timarpur plant was discussed. According to The Times of India, sources said that officials seemed confident of addressing the issue once the entire plant was ready.
The two plants under this project are slated to produce around 2.23 tonnes of refuse derived fuel annually while the biomethanation plant will use 100 tonnes of waste to churn out 5000 cubic metres of biogas daily. The fuel will be used to produce 16 MW of power. BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd will purchase half of the power that is produced. Power regulator, DERC, meanwhile recently passed an order on the tariff of the power produced by the plant at Rs 2.49/kWh (5.5 cents/kWh) for the first year and specified that any surplus power from the plant should be sold to a third party.
TWA has been raising the adverse environmental health consequences of such technologies since 2000 and the issue of these projects since March 2005.
Angry Rally Against Incinerator based Waste to Energy Projects
Mere shifting of location of the hazardous technology based plant not enough, such technologies should be abandoned
On the 23rd of March 2011 waste pickers marched from Delhi’s Kudeshiya Park (near ISBT) to Lt. Governor Office to demand the immediate stoppage of the waste-to-energy plants in Delhi at Okhla- Timarpur (16 MW) and Gazipur (10 MW). Notably, a US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) report availvle on its website observes that the energy generated from municipal waste is costlier than nuclear energy.
The rally was planned today to celebrate the martyardom of Shahid Bhagat Singh, the tallest revolutionary freedom fighter of the country.
Environmental and labour groups have been protesting against these plants since March 2005 and have been joined in by the affected local residents. The plants which got environmental clearance during the tenure of A Raja as Environment Minister are highly suspect and deserve to be reviewed and cancelled.
The proposed polluting technology to deal with the waste from South Delhi, North West Delhi and East Delhi is fraught with disastrous public health consequences for which two companies namely, Timarpur-Okhla Waste Management Company (TOWMCL) and the Unique Waste Processing Company (subsidiary of IL&FS Infrastructure Development Corporation Limited) have been set up. The Timarpur-Okhla carbon credit project was registered on 10th November, 2007 with a claim to reduce greenhouse gases to the tune of 262,791 metric tonnes CO2 equivalent per annum. Unique Waste Processing Company, a subsidiary of Infrastructure Leasing and Financial Services (IL&FS) and Andhra Pradesh Technology Development Centre (APTDC) has incorporated Timarpur-Okhla Waste Management Company for developing the project for processing municipal waste and also to produce electricity at two locations namely Timarpur and Okhla, at the site at Okhla that is adjacent to defunct Okhla Sewage Treatment Plant (STP).
TOWMCL is working with New Delhi Municipal Council (NDMC) and MCD. The Timarpur and Okhla plant will together be processing 650 tonnes per day of MSW at Timarpur site and 1300 tonnes per day of MSW at Okhla and claims to generate 16 MW of electricity. The Gazipur plant will process 1300 tonnes per day of MSW and claims to generate 10 MW of electricity.
It is scientifically established that the plants will emit hazardous pollutants, such as dioxins, which will eventually enter the food chain. Government cannot be allowed to experiment with Delhi’s health. These incinerators are coming up in clear violation of Supreme Court rulings on such plants. “In 2007 the Supreme Court allowed five pilot plants on an experimental basis and that too based only on biological treatment rather than incineration.”
The Supreme Court’s ruling is supported by the White Paper produced by the Ministry of Environment and Forests, stating, “The government claims that this plant will generate electricity, but it will only generate dioxins and other toxic emissions.” Comtroller Auditor General of India (CAG) and Delhi High Court have rebuked the concerned ministries for treating Delhi citizens as guinea pig for experimental technologies that have been tried and have failed.
In such a backdrop, Waste pickers have marched along with Residents, Citizens, Civil society groups, Human rights associations, Environmentalists, Students, Social Activists, NGOs, Trade Unions demanding stoppage of toxic waste to energy plants in Okhla, Timarpur and Gazipur.
THEIR DEMANDS ARE AS UNDER
* Union Government should remove incinerator technologies from its waste to energy policy being bulldozed by the Ministry of New & Renewable Energy down the throat of State Governments
* Delhi Government Should Desist from violating Supreme Court’s Order and endangering the public health of Delhi residents
* Mere shifting of the location of the hazardous technology based plant is insufficient, such technologies must be abandoned
* Central and State Government should stop with immediate effect the proposed waste to energy plants in Timarpur, Sukhdev Vihar (Okhla) and Gazipur and high cost routes for waste management must be avoided, instead only appropriate methods such as small-scale bio-methanation, composting and proper recycling be propagated.
* Central and State Government should give legal recognition to wastepickers and their role in the collection, segregation and recycling of waste. About 3.5 lakhs of urban poor, mostly migrated from rural areas in search of livelihood, are involved in the waste management informal sector. Wastepickers should be given legal entitlement for the access to and management of waste.
* Central and State Government must take cognizance of the threat to waste pickers’ livelihood. Therefore, municipal waste should not be handed over to private companies. Privatization of the municipal solid waste management should be halted immediately.
* Central and State Government should adopt policies which explicitly aim to reduce resource consumption and associated waste generation. Delhi generates approximately 10.000 Tonnes of waste per day, of which 50% is organic, 30% is recyclable and 20% inert. Both organic waste can be composted and recyclable materials can be managed by wastepickers. Therefore only the inert fraction should be diverted in the sanitation landfills in order to face Delhi’s problem of landfill locations.
* Central and State Government should commit to maximizing recycling, minimizing landfilling, and eliminating incineration altogether. Recycling (including composting and other appropriate systems for managing organics) is strongly preferable to waste disposal on virtually every criterion: greenhouse gas emissions, the release of toxins, employment, social inclusion, sustainability, and public expenditure.
* Central and State Government should recognize the informal recycling sector’s contribution to climate change mitigation; and, when undertaking initiatives in the waste sector, should adopt inclusive and comprehensive planning processes that give wastepickers a voice and vote at every stage of project and policy design.
* Central and State Government should build upon the strengths of existing wastepicker networks with investments and technical support to increase recycling while ensuring decent livelihoods for all workers and traders in the recycling economy.
A delgation of wastepickers went to meet the Lt Governor who had deputed Ms Padmini Singhla, Additional Secretary to LG for recieving the petition from the waste pickers. She heard the gnawing concerns of a Dioxins emitting technology and informed the delegation comprising of TOXICSWATCH ALLIANCE, All India Kabadi Mazdoor Mahasangh and other partcipating organisations that Mr Sanjiv Mittal, OSD to LG will look into the matter and apprise the LG. It has reliably been learnt that Prime Minister has asked the LG to look into the matter and Union Environment Minister has asked Delhi Chief Minister to attend to the concerns of the residents against the toxic plants.